This book is a study of ‘collecting’ undertaken by Joseph Antoine Bruni d’Entrecasteaux and his shipmates in Tasmania, the western Pacific Islands, and Indonesia. In 1791–1794 Bruni d’Entrecasteaux led a French naval expedition in search of the lost vessels of La Pérouse which had last been seen by Europeans at Botany Bay in March 1788. After Bruni d’Entrecasteaux died near the end of the voyage and the expedition collapsed in political disarray in Java, its collections and records were subsequently scattered or lost.
The book’s core is a richly illustrated examination, analysis, and catalog of a large array of ethnographic objects collected during the voyage, later dispersed, and recently identified in museums in France, Norway, the Netherlands, Switzerland, and the United States. The focus on artifacts is informed by a broad conception of collecting as grounded in encounters or exchanges with Indigenous protagonists and also as materialized in other genres—written accounts, vocabularies, and visual representations (drawings, engravings, and maps).
Historically, the book outlines the antecedents, occurrences, and aftermath of the voyage, including its location within the classic era of European scientific voyaging (1766–1840) and within contemporary colonial networks. Particular chapters trace the ambiguous histories of the extant collections. Ethnographically, contributors are alert to local settings, relationships, practices, and values; to Indigenous uses and significance of objects; to the reciprocal, dialogic nature of collecting; to local agency or innovation in exchanges; and to present implications of objects and their histories, especially for modern scholars and artists, both Indigenous and non-Indigenous.
Abbreviations Preface and Acknowledgements
PART I: PROLOGUE 1 History — Contexts, Voyage, People, Collections – Bronwen Douglas Feature: The ‘Effets’ (effects) plates – Bronwen Douglas 2 Ethnohistory — Collecting and Representing – Bronwen Douglas
PART II: ARTEFACT COLLECTIONS 3 Object Trajectories, Webs of Relationships – Fanny Wonu Veys 4 Musée du Quai Branly – Jacques Chirac, Paris – Bronwen Douglas Feature: bwar — Kanak hache-ostensoir, ceremonial axe – Bronwen Douglas Feature: sisi fale — Tongan coconut fibre waist garment – Billie Lythberg and Melenaite Taumoefolau 5 Musée des Beaux-Arts, Dunkerque – Claude Steen-Guélen and Hélène Guiot Feature: kie — Tongan small fine mat – Hélène Guiot 6 Universitetsmuseet, Bergen – Knut Rio Feature: Encountering Māori and their artefacts – Billie Lythberg and Mānuka Hēnare Feature Archery equipment – Andy Mills 7 Kulturhistorisk Museum, University of Oslo – Arne Aleksej Perminow 8 Museum Volkenkunde – Nationaal Museum van Wereldculturen, Leiden – Fanny Wonu Veys Feature Tongan ships carving Fanny Wonu Veys Feature helu tu‘u — Tongan comb and hair dressing – Billie Lythberg and Melenaite Taumoefolau 9 Tropenmuseum – Nationaal Museum van Wereldculturen, Leiden – Tristan Mostert 10 Zeeuws Museum, Middelburg – Caroline van Santen 11 Peabody Museum of Archaeology and Ethnology at Harvard University, Cambridge, MA – Fanny Wonu Veys Feature kali — Tongan headrests – Fanny Wonu Veys_ 12 Musée cantonal d’Archéologie et d’Histoire, Lausanne – Claire Brizon, Claude Leuba, and Lionel Pernet with Fanny Wonu Veys and Bronwen Douglas Feature Absent objects, Muséum d’Histoire naturelle du Havre – Thierry Vincent
PART III: OTHER COLLECTIONS 13 Drawings and Engravings – Bronwen Douglas Feature tayenebe, exchange — Reviving Aboriginal fibre work in Tasmania – Julie Gough Feature kupesi — Tongan design structure and Piron’s experiment – Billie Lythberg and Semisi Fetokai Potauaine 14 Tongan Wordlists – Paul Geraghty 15 Tongan Musical Instruments – Fanny Wonu Veys, Billie Lythberg, and Rachel Hand with Tavake-fai-‘ana Semisi Fetokai Potauaine
PART IV: RE-INTERPRETATIONS AND TRANSFORMATIONS 16 Cultural Currents — Tongan and Fijian Sculpture – Andy Mills 17 Tongans in 1793 Phyllis Herda and Bronwen Douglas 18 Translation and Transformation — Piron’s Drawings – Nicola Dickson Feature Lisa Reihana’s Emissaries – Billie Lythberg
PART V: EPILOGUE 19 Reflections Nicholas Thomas
PART VI: CATALOGUE Appendix 1 Catalogue of the objects – Fanny Wonu Veys, Billie Lythberg, and Andy Mills Appendix 2 List of Objects by Institution – Fanny Wonu Veys and Billie Lythberg Appendix 3 List of Objects by Provenance – Fanny Wonu Veys and Bronwen Douglas
Contributors Figures References Index
Bronwen Douglas Is Honorary Professor At The Australian National University In Canberra Where She Was Fellow And Senior Fellow From 1997–2012. She Was Previously Lecturer And Senior Lecturer At La Trobe University (Melbourne, Australia) From 1971–1996.
A Historian Of Science Focussing On Oceania, Her Main Research Field Is The Interplay Of Global Ideas Of Human Difference, Race, And Geography In European Encounters With Particular Oceanian People, Places, And Agency. Her Conceptual Interests Include Materiality And Use Of Visual Materials, Maps, And Objects As Ethnohistorical Texts.
She Is Single Author Of Science, Voyages, And Encounters In Oceania 1511–1850 (Palgrave, 2014), Across The Great Divide: Journeys In History And Anthropology (Harwood, 1998), And More Than 70 Scholarly Articles And Book Chapters. She Co-Edited (With Chris Ballard) Foreign Bodies: Oceania And The Science Of Race 1750-1940 (Anu E Press, 2008) And (With Nicholas Thomas And Anna Cole) Tattoo: Bodies, Art And Exchange In The Pacific And The West (Reaktion, 2005). She Edited Or Co-Edited Special Issues Of Oceania (74, 2003), Journal Of Pacific History (47, 2012), Journal Of Colonialism And Colonial History (18, 2017), And History And Anthropology (Forthcoming). She Is Currently Editor Of The Journal Of Pacific History And Co-Editor Of Palgrave Studies In Pacific History.
Fanny Wonu Veys Is Curator Oceania At The National Museum Of World Cultures, A Dutch Umbrella Organization Comprising The Tropenmuseum, Amsterdam; Museum Volkenkunde, Leiden; The Afrika Museum, Berg En Dal; And The Wereldmuseum, Rotterdam. She Has Previously Worked At The Museum Of Archaeology And Anthropology In Cambridge (Uk) (2004–2006, 2008–2009) And Has Held Postdoctoral Fellowships At The Metropolitan Museum Of Art (New York) (2006–2007) And At The Musée Du Quai Branly (Paris) (2007–2008).
She Curated The Mana Māori Exhibition (2010–2011) In Leiden And Published A Book With The Same Title. She Co-Curated A Barkcloth Exhibition Tapa, Étoffes Cosmiques D’océanie In Cahors (France).
Her Fieldwork Sites Include New Zealand (Since 2000), Tonga (Since 2003) And More Recently Arnhem Land, Australia (Since 2014). Her Topics Of Interest And Expertise Include Pacific Art And Material Culture, Museums And Cultures Of Collecting, Pacific Musical Instruments, Pacific Textiles, And The Significance Of Historical Objects In A Contemporary Setting. She Has Published Numerous Articles In Journals And Books. Her Most Recent Single-Authored Book Is Unwrapping Tongan Barkcloth: Encounters, Creativity And Female Agency (Bloomsbury, 2017).
Billie Lythberg Has Been Senior Research Fellow At The University Of Auckland Business School (Nz) Since 2013, Working At The Junction Of Economics, Anthropology, And History. Her Research Interests Include Oceanic Sciences, Arts, And Oral Histories; Cross-Cultural Theories Of Value, Valuables, And Valuation; Sustainability And Environmental Management; And Social Innovation.
She Was Previously A Postdoctoral Fellow At Cambridge University’s Museum Of Archaeology And Anthropology (Maa, Uk) For The Artefacts Of Encounter Project (2010–2013). She Is Currently Affiliated To Pacific Presences (Maa, Uk) And Pacific Spaces (Auckland University Of Technology, Nz) And An Investigator On Three Royal Society Research Projects At The University Of Auckland: Te Ao Hou: Transforming Worlds In New Zealand 1900–1950, Ancient Futures: Late 18th- And Early 19th-Century Tongan Arts And Their Legacies, And Tāngata Tiriti: Learning The Trick Of Standing Upright Here.
She Has Published Extensively In Journals And Books, Co-Edited Special Issues Of The Journal Of Material Culture (17, 2012) And The Journal Of The Polynesian Society (Forthcoming 2018), Is On The Editorial Board Of The Journal Of Pacific History, And Is Contributing Editor For Arts Of Oceania To Smarthistory, The Official Partner To Khan Academy For Art History. She Co-Edited (With Nicholas Thomas, Julie Adams, Maia Nuku, And Amiria Salmond) Artefacts Of Encounter: Cook’s Voyages, Colonial Collecting And Museum Histories (University Of Otago Press, 2016).